WWW.THESIS.DISLIB.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Online materials, documents
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



«IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF FLORIDA SECOND DISTRICT BETHANY TRACE OWNERS' ) ASSOCIATION, INC., a Florida nonprofit ) corporation, ) ) ...»

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TO FILE REHEARING

MOTION AND, IF FILED, DETERMINED

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL

OF FLORIDA

SECOND DISTRICT

BETHANY TRACE OWNERS' )

ASSOCIATION, INC., a Florida nonprofit ) corporation, ) ) Appellant, ) ) v. ) Case No. 2D13-2792 ) WHISPERING LAKES I, LLC, a Florida ) limited liability company; and ) WATERMEN-PINNACLE, INC., a ) Florida corporation, f/k/a Bethany Trace ) Estates, Inc., ) ) Appellees. ) ) Opinion filed December 3, 2014.

Appeal from the Circuit Court for Lee County; Keith R. Kyle, Judge.

Matthew S. Toll and Thomas S. Heidkamp of Toll Law, Cape Coral, for Appellant.

Steven H. Mezer of Bush Ross, P.A., Tampa, for Appellee Whispering Lakes I, LLC.

Scott A. Beatty of Henderson, Franklin, Starnes & Holt, P.A., Bonita Springs, for Appellee Watermen-Pinnacle, Inc.

VILLANTI, Judge.

Bethany Trace Owners' Association, Inc. (the Association), appeals the final summary judgment entered in favor of Whispering Lakes I, LLC, and WatermenPinnacle, Inc., in this case arising out of the ownership of certain lands associated with the Bethany Trace subdivision. Because the trial court entered summary judgment based on an interpretation of the relevant documents that renders portions of them meaningless and because a plausible alternate interpretation gives meaning to all of the provisions, we reverse the final summary judgment and remand for further proceedings.

In the early 1990s, Lehigh Corporation began developing a tract of land in Lee County for a subdivision that was to be called Bethany Trace. As part of the original development of the subdivision, Lehigh Corporation prepared a Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions & Easements (the Declaration). The Declaration

contained the following definition of the "Common Areas" related to the subdivision:

1.6. "Common Areas" mean those tracts, easements or areas of land shown on any recorded subdivision plat of the Property which are intended to be devoted to the general common use and enjoyment of the Owners in the Property, which shall include without limitation, any areas denoted thereon as a common area, including any fences

–  –  –

(Exhibit B), the Lake Maintenance Area (Exhibit C), the Park Areas (Exhibit D), and the Conservation Area and the Conservation Buffer Area (Exhibit E). The Declaration and its exhibits were recorded in the public records of Lee County on September 23, 1994.

On September 13, 2001, Lehigh Corporation assigned its rights and obligations under the Declaration to Watermen.1 In that assignment, Watermen agreed to "convey to the Association, for no further consideration and free and clear of any liens or encumbrances, those Common Areas referred to [as] 'Bethany Lake', the 'Lake Maintenance Area', the 'Park Area', and the 'Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area', as those areas are described in the Declaration." Rather than doing so, Watermen sold those lands to Whispering Lakes, which bulldozed certain improvements on them, apparently in anticipation of building additional residences in the area.

–  –  –

Association sued Watermen for breach of contract and sued Whispering Lakes for breach of covenant and trespass. Watermen and Whispering Lakes subsequently moved for summary judgment, arguing that the language of the Declaration clearly showed that the Association had no legally cognizable interest in any of the identified lands as a matter of law and that therefore Watermen and Whispering Lakes were entitled to judgment in their favor.

Prior to the assignment, Lehigh Corporation changed its name to Florida Landmark Communities, Inc. And the assignment was actually made to Watermen's predecessor-in-interest, Bethany Trace Estates, Inc. However, because there is no dispute concerning the corporate identity of any of the parties, we simply refer to them as Lehigh and Watermen for ease of reference.

–  –  –

definition of "Common Areas" in section 1.6 of the Declaration. They contended that the first sentence of that definition, which refers to lands identified as common areas on a recorded plat, applies to the entire definition and means that only those areas identified as common areas on a recorded plat are "Common Areas," regardless of any other language in the Declaration. They contended that since no plat of the Bethany Trace subdivision was ever recorded, no "Common Areas" ever came into existence and therefore Watermen never had any obligations toward the Association as to any "Common Areas." They also contended that the identification of Bethany Lake, the Lake Maintenance Area, the Park Areas, and the Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area in the definition of "Common Areas" was nothing more than an illustration of what some "Common Areas" might be if and when the developer actually recorded a plat.

The Association, on the other hand, argued that the definition of "Common Areas" in section 1.6 contemplates four different types of common areas: (1) those identified on a recorded plat if one is subsequently recorded; (2) water management and conservation tracts, including Bethany Lake, the Lake Maintenance Area, the Park Areas, and the Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area; (3) improvements constructed on any of the foregoing areas; and (4) additional areas designated by the developer at some later time. Thus, the Association argued that the lack of a recorded plat did not affect its ownership interest in Bethany Lake, the Lake Maintenance Area, the Park Areas, and the Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area because

–  –  –





Watermen and Whispering Lakes. Thus, it found that the Association had no ownership interest of any kind in Bethany Lake, the Lake Maintenance Area, the Park Areas, and the Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area because neither the original developer nor any subsequent assignee had ever recorded a plat for the subdivision.

And because the Association had no ownership interest in these lands, neither Watermen nor Whispering Lakes breached any contract or covenant to convey those rights or could commit a trespass as a matter of law. On the basis of these findings, the trial court entered final summary judgment in favor of Watermen and Whispering Lakes, and the Association now seeks review.

–  –  –

Jackson v. Shakespeare Found., Inc., 108 So. 3d 587, 593 (Fla. 2013); Vollmer v. Key Fin. Corp., 810 So. 2d 966, 968 (Fla. 2d DCA 2002). Because the interpretation of a contract is a question of law, this court may reach a construction or interpretation of the contract contrary to that of the trial court. See, e.g., Gemini Ventures of Tampa, Inc. v.

Hamilton Eng'g & Surveying, Inc., 784 So. 2d 1179, 1180 (Fla. 2d DCA 2001); Whitley v. Royal Trails Prop. Owners' Ass'n, 910 So. 2d 381, 385 (Fla. 5th DCA 2005). When interpreting contractual provisions, courts "will not interpret a contract in such a way as to render provisions meaningless when there is a reasonable interpretation that does not do so." Moore v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 916 So. 2d 871, 877 (Fla. 2d DCA 2005); see also Publix Super Markets, Inc. v. Wilder Corp. of Del., 876 So. 2d 652, 654

–  –  –

to give meaning to all provisions while doing violence to none.

In this case, the interpretation of section 1.6 as requiring a recorded plat to create any and all "Common Areas" unjustifiably ignores other sections of the Declaration that clearly give the Association ownership rights and obligations in Bethany Lake, the Lake Maintenance Area, the Park Area, and the Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area. For example, article II of the Declaration, entitled "Land

Plan," contains the following relevant provisions:

–  –  –

(Emphasis added.) Article VI of the Declaration requires the Association to maintain Bethany Lake and the Lake Maintenance Area. Article IX of the Declaration identifies the Association's expenses as those necessary to "own and maintain the Common Areas, including without limitation, the Park Areas, Bethany Lake and the Lake Maintenance Area, [and] to preserve and monitor the Conservation Area and the Conservation Buffer Area." That same article requires the Association to insure and maintain—and collect assessments to pay for the maintenance of—these identified lands. Finally, article VII of the Declaration makes the Association responsible for the removal of invasive exotic species in the Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area.

It is clear from the language of the entire Declaration that the Association was given ownership rights and obligations in Bethany Lake, the Lake Maintenance Area, the Park Area, and the Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area that are separate and apart from some otherwise generic "common areas" that might be identified on some future recorded plat. None of the Association's obligations as to these specifically identified lands are contingent on the developer subsequently recording a separate plat that identifies them as "Common Areas." Instead, it is clear from a reading of the entire Declaration that the ownership rights and obligations as to these identified lands spring from the Declaration itself. And this interpretation is further reinforced by section 10.12 of the Declaration, which permits the developer to add

–  –  –

by recording a new subdivision plat.

Additional support for this interpretation of section 1.6 comes from the language of the assignment from Lehigh Corporation to Watermen. That assignment required Watermen to convey to the Association "those Common Areas referred to as 'Bethany Lake', the 'Lake Maintenance Area', the 'Park Area', and the 'Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area.' " This phrasing indicates that these identified lands are separate and apart from any general "common areas" that might otherwise exist. And an interpretation of section 1.6 as requiring a recorded plat before any interest arose in these identified lands would render Watermen's obligation to convey them to the Association illusory since it was undisputed that no plat of Bethany Trace had been recorded in the years between 1994, when the Declaration was recorded, and 2001, when the assignment was signed.

Here, the interpretation adopted by the trial court results in portions of the Declaration being meaningless. It ignores those portions of the Declaration that state that the Association shall own and maintain Bethany Lake, the Lake Maintenance Area, the Park Area, and the Conservation Area and Conservation Buffer Area, and it also renders the obligation of the developer to convey legal title to these lands to the Association meaningless. The Association's interpretation, on the other hand, is a reasonable interpretation that gives meaning to all of the provisions of the Declaration and the subsequent assignment. Therefore, we reverse the final summary judgment in favor of Watermen and Whispering Lakes and remand for further proceedings.

–  –  –

DAVIS, C.J., and KELLY, J., Concur.



Similar works:

«Bermuda opening statement This is the Second Public Hearing held by the Commission of Inquiry established by the Hon Premier Michael Dunkley on 24th February 2016. Notice of the Hearing was first given in our Opening Statement at our first Hearing on June 27th. It was confirmed in our Press Statement on 12th September 2016 which also advised that the Premier had provided an extension to the Commission until December 31 2016. Let me introduce again the Commission members, myself as chairman of...»

«National Jesuit Committee on Investment Responsibility National Jesuit Committee on Investment Responsibility 2014 Review Contents Invitation to Participate Chairperson's Message Our Strategy A Commentary NJCIR Selection Guidelines: Prayerful Discernment by John Sealey Our Engagements on the Sustainable Use of Water Bunge Limited Ingredion Our Engagements on Promoting Human Rights GEO Group, Inc. Monsanto Company Aura Minerals Inc. A Jesuit Reflects Global Awareness, Human Rights and Our...»

«Case 1:10-cv-00065-jpj -pms Document 44 Filed 05/13/11 Page 1 of 43 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA ABINGDON DIVISION DORIS BETTY ADDISON, on behalf of herself [and] all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, AMENDED v. REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION CNX GAS COMPANY, LLC; Case No. 1:10cv00065 COMMONWEALTH COAL CORPORATION; and JOHN DOES A -Z, Defendants. This case comes before the court on defendants’ motions to dismiss, (Docket Item Nos. 12, 16) (AMotions@). The Motions...»

«1 Convergence and Consensus in Public Reason Kevin Vallier Reasonable individuals often share a rationale for a decision but, in other cases, they make the same decision based on disparate and often incompatible rationales. The social contract tradition has been divided between these two methods of solving the problem of social cooperation: must social cooperation occur in terms of common reasoning or can individuals with different doctrines simply converge on shared institutions for their own...»

«Manuscript Collections Home Finding Aid to the Baldwin Corporation Records Baldwin Corporation Records, 1823-1954 (bulk 1898-1936) 31.6 linear ft. Collection number: Mss 160 History Scope and Content Box and Folder List OVERVIEW Access: The collection is open under the rules and regulations of the Institute. Provenance: Donated by Karl P. and George N. Baldwin, November-December 1960 (Acc. 1116) Property rights: The Institute for Regional Studies owns the property rights to this collection....»

«Hindu Temple and Cultural  Center of South Carolina 5703 Kiawah Road, Columbia, SC 29212. Phone: (803) 772-9650 www.hindutemplesc.org | www.facebook.com/htccsc Tax ID: 57-074-6252 Newsletter: Dec 2013 Board of Trustees Temple Timings Chairman Emeritus Dr. Kaushal K Sinha Monday to Friday 8:30 am to 12:00 pm Chairman Suresh Topiwala 5:00 pm to 8:30 pm Vice Chairman Sarat Babu Gorrepati Saturday & Sunday 8:00 am to 1:00 pm Secretary Rajesh Verma 5:00 pm to 8:30 pm Member Arunima Sinha Daily...»

«MessageOps Microsoft Online PowerShell Extensions Installation and Reference Guide www.MessageOps.com info@messageops.com www.MessageOps.com Contents Introduction Installation Usage Get-MessageOps-EWSURL Get-MessageOps-AutoDiscover Get-MessageOps-MailboxSize Get-MessageOps-MobileDevice Get-MessageOps-Messages Export-MessageOps-MessageToEml Export-MessageOps-MessagesToDirectory Download-MessageOps-AttachmentToFile Set-MessageOps-MarkasRead Get-MessageOps-FolderStatistics...»

«Privacy Impact Assessment Update for the E-Verify Mobile App Usability Testing DHS/USCIS/PIA-030(f) January 15, 2016 Contact Point Donald K. Hawkins Privacy Officer United States Citizenship Immigration Services (202) 272-8030 Reviewing Official Karen L. Neuman Chief Privacy Officer Department of Homeland Security (202) 343-1717 Privacy Impact Assessment DHS/USCIS/PIA-030(f) E-Verify Mobile App Page 1 Abstract The Department of Homeland Security (DHS), United States Citizenship and Immigration...»

«HEFT Equality Strategy and EDS Framework HEFT Equality Strategy & Equality Delivery System 2012 2016 HEFT Equality Strategy and EDS Framework META DATA Title: HEFT Equality Strategy & EDS Framework 2010 2013 Date: January 202 Review Date: January 2016 Created By: Equality and Diversity Department Source: Equality and Diversity Department Stored Centrally: Trust Intranet and Internet Linked Trust Policies: Bullying and Harassment • Confidentiality • Consent to Examination or Treatment •...»

«Slovenian Presidency of the EU Council, 1 January 2008 to 30 June 2008, Home Affairs We have justified the confidence shown in Slovenia Photo: UKOM President of the EU Council for the field of Home Affairs and Slovenian Minister of the Interior Dragutin Mate On 22 January 2008 Dragutin Mate, President of the EU Home Affairs Council and Slovenian Minister of the Interior, presented the priority tasks of the Slovenian Presidency in the field of internal affairs before the European Parliament. His...»

«Brief Bio Sketch of Professor Abbas Firoozabadi Abbas Firoozabadi has published some 180 Journal papers in petroleum interfaces, thermodynamics of hydrocarbon reservoirs and production, and multiphasemultispecies flow in permeable media. He has published mainly in the Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE) Journals, AIChE Journal, Journal of Chemical Physics, Journal of Physical Chemistry B and C, Langmuir, Water Resources Research, Advances in Water Resources, Soft Matter, and Journal of...»

«2015 Wilton LCM Senior Invitational October 17-18, 2015 Wilton Family YMCA 404 Danbury Rd. Wilton, CT. 06897 http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&tab=wl Held under sanction of USA Swimming and Connecticut Swimming #S15-10 In granting this sanction it is understood and agreed that USA Swimming and Connecticut Swimming, Inc. shall be free and held harmless from any liabilities or claims for damages arising by reason of injuries to anyone during the conduct of the event.EVENTS: Name Email Phone Meet...»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.thesis.dislib.info - Online materials, documents

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.