FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Online materials, documents

Pages:   || 2 | 3 |

«DO WE NEED INTERNAL AUDIT, FINANCIAL AUDIT OR COACHING? PETRAȘCU Daniela1 “Lucian Blaga” University, Sibiu Abstract The present paper does not ...»

-- [ Page 1 ] --

Revista Economică 66:5 (2014)




“Lucian Blaga” University, Sibiu


The present paper does not wish to be merely a brief parallel between the

financial audit and the internal audit, but it aims at pointing out their importance for

any economic entity, especially the importance of the benefits it can offer both to the

current management and to coaching. Starting from the premise that audit is not a control and that auditors are not the adversaries of an entity, the aim is to show that the scope of audit missions should concretize in added value.

Keywords: internal audit, financial audit, coaching, fiscal audit The research methodology to which I appealed in creating the present paper consisted of the analysis and systematization of the specialized literature and that of the national and international norms which regulate the auditing activity.

In view of accomplishing the aforementioned objective, I used as main method of research, the following: qualitative analysis, within which the method of comparison can be found, a method which views the drawing of a parallel between the forms of audit; synthesis: found in drawing the conclusions which regard the explanation and the appreciation of the acknowledged situation, the limits and the characteristics of audit, respectively, and, last but not least, the documentation, as a theoretical method of research within which I comprised the analysis of the norms issued on a national and international level, regarding the auditing activity, as well as the Assistant Professor, PhD.

Revista Economică 66:5 (2014) analysis of the works published in the field by various internationally renowned authors.

Internal audit The audit, in general, is a systematic process of objective acquirement and evaluation of some pieces of information or affirmations regarding the assessment of their degree of conformity with the pre-established criteria, as well as a process of communication of results to the interested users (American Accounting Asociatim).

The audit consists of verifying and certifying of the financial situations by and independent expert in view of expressing an opinion regarding the reality and exactness of the data contained therein. The role of the audit is to ensure the users of information in what regards respecting the accounting principles and practices, as well as informing them about the presentation in accounting and in financial statements of a clear, complete and real image of the financial position and performances of the company.

(Giurgiu A, Ungureanu P., Duma F., 2009, p. 28.).

From the analysis of the definitions given to the audit, in general we

can assume the following traits:

1. The audit is a process, a set of operations, of collecting, analysis and evaluation of the information (audit evidence) in view of acquiring an assurance regarding the conformity or non-conformity of these pieces of information or of the declarations with pre-established criteria.

In essence, an auditing process consists of: collecting the just and plenty of audit evidence necessary for expressing an opinion or for formulating a recommendation; the evaluation of the accordance or disagreement between the different types of collected evidence; establishing the obliquity from the pre-established norms. (Petrascu D, 2012, p.8).

2. The audit confronts the applied accounting policies and the utilized work procedures within the entity with a set of pre-established criteria, such as The International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), the International Accounting Standards (IAS), the national accounting regulations, the manuals of internal procedures, fiscal regulations, etc. In order for them to be useful, these confrontations must be based on verifiable and justifiable information.

3. The auditors are competent professionals who have obtained this quality based on certain exams. The examination of the information is not done randomly, according to the auditors’ intuition, but by professional Revista Economică 66:5 (2014) standards (ethical conduct established through Codes of Profession and through the VII-th Directive of the CCE from 1984, professional standards and work standards).

The conclusions of the auditors are synthetized and systematized in the rapports which are made available to those who are interested. (Oprean I., Popa I., Lenghe R.l,, 2007, pp 97-98.). In the year 1999, The International Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) from USA issued a new definition of internal audit, following a study conducted with the help of 800 students, coordinated by the auditors from the Australian universities, like this: (Ghiţă M., Popescu M., 2006, p.35) the internal audit examines the entity’s activities and services, first of all, in order to improve them. He leads to the strict application of the policies and procedures instituted by the respective entity and is not limited to the financial aspects.(Jinga C., 2009, p. 54).

The internal audit constitutes a function of the control structure of the entity. It must not be confused with the entity’s internal control structure.

The two departments are distinct and independent, and are not in a relation of subordination (Jinga C., 2009, p. 54). The internal auditors are permanent employees of the company and are subordinated directly to the company’s management or to the General Assembly of Shareholders. The possibility of calling upon the services offered in this field by specialized companies (expert accountants, financial auditors) through the conclusion of service contracts is not excluded.

The internal auditor counsels, assists, recommends, but does not decide, his obligation being that of representing a means which contributes to the improvement of the control each manager has upon his activities, as well as upon of those who are in coordinating positions, in view of reaching the objectives. (Ghiţă M., et. al, Idem., p. 32). To summarize: the internal audit is a profession which has always been constantly re-defined over the years, from the wish of answering to the ever-changing necessities of the entities, his object of activity shifting from the analysis of the accounting and financial problems to tracking down the main risks of the entities and the evaluation of their internal control. (Jucan N.C., Sibiu, 2011, p. 71).

The financial audit: the simple denomination of “financial audit “can

be used to designate various other missions, such as:

 The financial auditing of the computerized procedures of book keeping;

Revista Economică 66:5 (2014)  The financial audit of the exchange operations in order to verify their presentation according to regulations within the financial statements;

 The financial audit of the accounted social spending in order to verify that the social law is respected.

 The financial audit of the fiscal statements In other words, any kind of analysis, any kind of control, any kind of verification and any kind of study regarding a section or a part of the accounting or the financial statements of an entity may qualify as ‘financial audit’.

This means that the financial audit may be considered as an audit, in general terms, with the exception that the competent and independent specialist must be a professional accountant, and the object of the examination consists of any kind of financial-accounting information.

The financial audit (Government Emergency Ordinance- GEO 75/1999 republished regarding the activity of auditing) consists of collecting evidence regarding the financial statements of a patrimonial entity and the use of the evidence in expressing, by the auditor, of an opinion regarding the conformity of their elaboration, presentation and publication according to an accepted financial reporting system. The objective (ISA 120 “The General Framework for the Preparation And Presentation Of Financial Statements Elaborated By The Committee for the International Accounting Standards”, appendix to the Order no.94/29 January 2001 of Ministry of Public FinancesMPF, published in the Official Monitor no.85/20, February 2001”); the financial audit consists of “expressing, by an auditor, of an opinion, according to which the financial statements have been prepared under all significant aspects, in conformity with a general framework identified by financial reporting”. The expressions used for expressing the auditor’s opinion are: “it gives a true and fair view” or “it presents in a true and fair way under all significant aspects”, terms which are “equivalents” Within the minimal auditing norms elaborated by the Chamber of Financial Auditors of Romania (CFAR) financial statements mean: balance sheet, profit and loss account, statement of changes in equity, cash-flow statements, and the notes to the accounts.

Defining the financial audit The financial audit comprises the annual financial statements, which are exposed to the examination executed by a COMPETENT and Revista Economică 66:5 (2014) INDEPENDENT professional, having the purpose of expressing a justified

opinion regarding:

 The correctness of applying the internal financial-accounting procedures, implemented by the management of the entity;

 The true and fair, clear and complete view of the patrimony, the financial statement and of the results obtained by the entity.

The main characteristics of the financial audit refer to:

The realization of the audit by a professional who is independent from the management of the unit;

It responds to the need of information of various users of information;

It examines periodically the documents, on the basis of a contract, usually concluded for a period of one year;

It analyses the financial-accounting operations, as well the internal financial control unfolded within the audited entity in order to express an opinion regarding the reliability of the financial-accounting documents.

It runs an accessory activity in what regards the discovery and caveat of fraud There are authors who separate the financial-accounting audit from the financial-fiscal audit.

The financial-accounting audit proposes to verify the compliance with the generally accepted conceptual framework of accounting (postulates, principles, norms and rules of assessment), the internal procedures established by the economic agent, as well as realization and certification of the reflection in accounting of the financial statements, of the true and fair, clear and complete view of them throughout the financial year (Stoian A., Ţurlea E., Auditul financiar contabil, Ed. Economică, Bucureşti, 2001. p. 13.).

The fiscal audit consists of the expression of an independent opinion regarding the fiscal activities, competencies, rights and obligations and it has as objective the evaluation of fiscal control, of risks in the field of taxes, fiscal policies and fiscal performance. (Boulescu M., Ghiţă M., Mareş V., Controlul fiscal şi auditul financiar-fiscal, Ed. CECCAR, Bucureşti, 2003, pg. 321-322).

From a judicial standpoint, there is legal audit and contractual audit:

(Creţoiu G., Bucur I., Contabilitate – Fundamentele şi noul cadru juridic, Ed.

C.H. Beck, Bucureşti, 2007, p.320).

Legal audit: represents the auditing mission which has as scope the certification of honesty, regularity and of the true and fair view of annual accounts, as well as the specific verification in what regards the compliance Revista Economică 66:5 (2014) with certain legal dispositions and other information. The notion of true and fair view is connected with the regularity and honesty of accounting. The regularity means the conformity with the rules and the general accounting procedures, depending on the knowledge those who are responsible of the accounts must have about the reality and the importance of the operations, events and statements within the company.

The contractual audit: it is private and un-institutional and it presupposes the establishment of a contract between client and auditor, to who the mission of auditing is proposed. This audit can be limited to auditing certain categories of documents issued by the enterprise (the audit of fiscal documents), auditing a single activity of the enterprise (auditing of sales) or to the auditing of one of the services of the enterprise (cash flow audit).

The analysis of these particularities underlines the existence of a single audit mission or legal control, which comprises the known objectives (certification, verifications, specification), but also a very large number of contractual audit missions. This situation is due to the multiple significations attributed to the term `audit`. Thus, audit can designate any contract concluded between an auditor and a client and it can constitute an activity of control, verification, revision, inspection etc. In these cases, numerous audits may appear in the form of consultation, analysis, evaluation, investigation, diagnostic, etc.(Alain Burlaud, (coord), Francois-Denis Poitrinal, Edouard Salustra, Compatabilite et droit comptable. L`intelligence des compts et leur cadre legal, Gualino editeur, Paris, 1998.) The objectives of financial audit are strongly connected to the information given by the management of the audited entity. In order to be able to draw a conclusion about the correctness and sincerity of the information provided by the management of the entity, the auditor id compelled to gather relevant and sufficient information in order for him to express his opinion regarding the compliance or non-compliance of annual financial statements with the legal regulations in effect.

Pages:   || 2 | 3 |

Similar works:

«Evaluating the efficacy of a government funded SME-programme in tourism in the Republic of South Africa By Adrinet Snyman (MA), Prof Melville Saayman and Wagied Alie Respectively Lecturer in the School for Entrepreneurship, Marketing and Tourism Management, Director and Lecturer for the Institute of Tourism and Leisure Studies and Programmes Manager of the National Business Initiative (NBI) North West University (Potchefstroom Campus) Private Bag X6001 Potchefstroom SOUTH AFRICA Tel: +27 18 299...»

«DRAFT 1.0 – Not for distribution Regenerative Capitalism Sept 15, 2013 Working Draft John Fullerton Capital Institute Regenerative Capitalism June DRAFT Capital Institute Table of Contents Preface A Summary Call to Regenerative Capitalism I. Introduction II. From Mechanistic to Ecological Worldview III. The Regenerative Paradigm IV. Regenerative Capitalism V. Regenerative Capitalism in Practice VI. Regenerative Finance VII. The Way Forward Bibliography Regenerative Capitalism June DRAFT...»

«Deconstructing Clusters: Chaotic Concept or Policy Panacea? Ron Martin Department of Geography University of Cambridge, UK E-mail: rlm1@cam.ac.uk and Peter Sunley Department of Geography University of Edinburgh, UK E-mail: pjs@geo.ed.ac.uk Acknowledgements Earlier versions of this paper were presented at the Regional Studies Association Conference on Regionalising the Knowledge Economy London, 21 November 2001; at the Cluster Workshop, University of Lund, Sweden, 5 April, 2002; at the High...»

«The Limits of Noise Trading: An Experimental Analysis By Robert Bloomfield, Maureen O’Hara, and Gideon Saar* First Draft: January 2005 This Version: February 2006 *Robert Bloomfield (rjb9@cornell.edu), Maureen O’Hara (mo19@cornell.edu) and Gideon Saar (gs25@cornell.edu) are from the Johnson Graduate School of Management, Cornell University. Financial support for this project was obtained from New York University's Salomon Center for the Study of Financial Institutions. We would like to...»

«Munich Personal RePEc Archive Evaluation of static hedging strategies for hydropower producers in the Nordic market Fleten, Stein-Erik; Br˚ athen, Espen and Nissen-Meyer, Sigurd-Erik Norwegian University of Science and Technology December 2010 Online at http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/27133/ MPRA Paper No. 27133, posted 01. December 2010 / 16:09 Evaluation of static hedging strategies for hydropower producers in the Nordic market Stein-Erik Fleten Department of Industrial Economics and...»

«Supporting UK business The report of the Business Finance Taskforce October 2010 Supporting UK business Contents 1 Contents Foreword 2 1 Executive summary 5 2 Current state of business lending markets 13 3 Restoring confidence – Taskforce commitments to business 32 4 Restoring confidence – how wholesale markets will help 46 5 Delivery milestones 54 Appendix A: Taskforce objectives i Appendix B: Supporting market data iii Appendix C: Stakeholders who have inputted into the Taskforce ix...»

«Dear Debenture holder, Sub.: Put Option Exercise Form, (“Form”) for Option I Secured Redeemable Non-Convertible Debentures of face value of Rs. 1,000 each (“NCDs”), issued by Shriram Transport Finance Company Limited, (the ’Company’), to the public pursuant to the Prospectus dated June 16, 2011 (the “Prospectus”) and the Debenture Trust Deed dated June28, 2011. As per the terms of Prospectus dated June 16, 2011 and the Debenture Trust deed dated June28, 2011, a Put/Call option...»

«“Shriram Transport Finance Company Limited Conference Call” July 23, 2013 MANAGEMENT: MR. UMESH REVANKAR Page 1 of 15 Shriram Transport Finance Company Limited July 23, 2013 Moderator: Ladies and gentlemen, good evening and welcome to the Shriram Transport Finance Q1 FY'14 Earnings Conference Call. As a reminder, all participant lines will be in the listen-only mode and there will be an opportunity for you to ask questions at the end of today’s presentation. Should you need assistance...»

«The Knights Templar School Minutes of the Governors’ Meeting held on Tuesday 12th February 2013 Please note : these minutes will be corrected, if necessary, and approved at the next meeting. Meanwhile, they will be treated as accurate, so please read them carefully and let the Clerk know if you notice any significant errors. If you want to raise items at the next meeting, they can be included on the agenda if GK gets them by the next Finance and General Purposes Meeting on Thursday 14th March...»

«Preliminary and incomplete.. Hacking Reverse Mortgages October 26, 2015 Deborah Lucas* *Sloan Distinguished Professor of Finance and Director MIT Center for Finance and Policy I am grateful to Thomas Davidoff, Doug Criscitello, Robert Merton, Mark Warshawsky and especially to Damien Moore for their many helpful insights and suggestions, and to Sung Kwan Lee and Yu Shi for capable research assistance. Any opinions expressed are my own and not those of the MIT Center for Finance and Policy....»

«Commodity Prices and Fiscal Policy in Latin America and the Caribbean Emily Sinnott First Draft: September 2009 Abstract The paper looks at how fiscal dependence on commodity production has emerged in recent years in Latin America and the Caribbean. Hydrocarbon and mining production remains an important and growing source of direct tax revenue for several economies in the region, with a substantial share of the region’s GDP generated in countries that are defined as hydrocarbon/mining...»

«DETERMINANTS OF FINANCING CHOICES IN THE MALAYSIAN PUBLIC LISTED COMPANIES HANITA KADIR @ SHAHAR DOCTOII OF PHlLOSOJ'HY LlNIVERSITI UTAKA MALAYSIA.J~lly DETERMINANTS OF FINANCING CHOICES IN THE MALAYSIAN PUBLIC LISTED COMPANIES BY HANITA KADIR @ SHAHAR 'l'hesis Submitted to Othman Yeop Abdullah Graduate School of Business, Universiti Utara Malaysia. In Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Kolej Perniagaan (College o f Business) Universiti Utara Malaysia Y. * @...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.thesis.dislib.info - Online materials, documents

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.